|
Dear Investors,
I used to only send out quarterly reports, but these
days much changes in a few days. We began our saga two
weeks ago, and in our September 9 update I listed a group
of financial companies in serious trouble. Most went
out of business the following week. Now, as we all know,
the Treasury Department and Federal Reserve Board have
decided they need to bail out the entire credit industry.
Yesterday Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson and Fed Chairman
Bernanke spoke to Congress, who did not receive their
plan particularly well. Hopefully they will be able to
agree on a plan very soon.
Senators complained that the
three page bill being proposed basically gives Mr. Paulson
nearly autocratic control over our financial companies.
Plus, the bill does not guarantee certain things that
many people consider important, such as executive compensation,
and making sure that homeowners who can pay a reasonable
mortgage don't lose their homes. Plus, does anyone think
we should have someone buying $700 billion worth of anything
without any oversight?
While I agree that some of these
details need to be filled in, the fact is that the people
in charge of this bailout must be able to act quickly
and flexibly when needed. But most importantly, I am
fairly certain that doing something like this bailout
may be the most likely way to avoid economic calamity.
In order to understand why this particular type of bailout
is necessary, a person needs to realize that the largest
and most imminent problems to our financial system are
due to the massive use and misuse of credit default swaps
(CDS), a type of derivative financial product designed
to guarantee bonds - mostly mortgage-backed bonds. Five
years ago Warren Buffett called them a "time bomb" and "financial
weapons of mass destruction," and he had his insurance
companies leave the credit default swap market. Mr. Buffett
said this market would most likely collapse at some point,
and last Monday it nearly did just that.
It is difficult
to conceive of how large this CDS market became over
the last few years. It is estimated to be over $70 trillion.
This is nearly the size of all the money in all the banks
in the world. And this financial structure was built
upon our mortgages, such that the $70 trillion monstrosity
was nearly certain to fall if our real estate market
ever got into trouble. AIG had to be bailed out because,
according to their CEO, they could not continue to keep
up their end of all the CDS trades once Lehman had failed.
AIG assured the Fed that, if they fell, a large number
of major financial institutions around the world would
all topple. As we know, the Fed then gave AIG $85 billion
to prevent this. But last week Morgan Stanley may have
started to crack under the pressure of their CDS obligations.
If Morgan Stanley had fallen, we would have had panic
in this country. To prevent this, Treasury and the Fed
entered in to try to fix the underlying problem with
their bailout. If they fail, $70 trillion worth of these
credit default swaps will crash on our financial system.
Fortunately, the new plan should have a good chance of
success. The underlying problems are the mortgages, as
the credit default swaps are mostly guaranteeing residential
mortgages. This plan should work because it will offer
at least a modestly more profitable way to dispose of
the troubled mortgages. It will also create a market
for the pools of mortgages. Finally, it will give all
the financial institutions time for the problems to work
out. With time, most of the mortgages should turn out
to be either profitable or have limited losses. This
then eliminates most of the credit default swap risk
based upon these mortgages.
Time was clearly not on their
side last week, and the entire financial system was seizing
up. This means that nobody would finance anyone else.
Unfortunately, without constant financing the investment
banks cannot last a week, and several didn't. But the
government is the one financial entity that has money
and won't go away (to the chagrin of many!). Their intervention
thereby stabilizes the situation and should give companies
confidence that they can continue to do business with
each other and the public.
While this bailout should
protect us against an ongoing financial crisis, even
if it works, this hardly leaves the U.S. economy in great
shape. Given this, many understandably wonder why a person
would want to own any U.S. stocks. In my next quarterly
letter, I will explain in some detail why it is still
a good time to own the best stock-based investments.
Of course, perhaps the best way to maintain a balanced
and opportunistic view on investing during dangerous
times is to watch and listen to Warren Buffett. Last
night he announced that he was investing $5 billion into
Goldman Sachs. Now for the last two weeks I have been
singing Goldman's praises. Last week's update said, "I
guarantee you Goldman Sachs is the prize. They are by
far the best, in profits, judgment, risk control, etc.,
etc. There isn’t a second in their group." And
the previous week's update said, "So while this
is terrible news for those who own Lehman Brothers’ stock,
which went down 45% on Tuesday, this may be great news
for their competitor Goldman Sachs, as Goldman did not
engage in any of the ill-advised activities Lehman undertook.
As a result, coming out of this mess, Goldman will be
able to grow and take over much of the market share left
behind by inferior companies such as Lehman." I
wanted to buy Goldman stock myself last week, but I find
it best to leave a decision like this to Mr. Buffett,
who knows the CEO of Goldman Sachs and who is the safest,
most successful investor in financial services over the
last 50 years.
Mr. Buffett's answer as to why he put
$5 billion into Goldman last night is essentially my
answer as to why we want to continue to own stock funds:
"We had a lot of cash, and we are now seeing things
that give us a chance to use that cash sensibly," Buffett
told CNBC television, referring to holdings at Berkshire
Hathaway." Five years from now, ten years from now,
we'll look back at this period and we'll say you could
have made some extraordinary buys," he continued. "The
American economy over a period of time will do very well,
and people that own a piece of it will do very well."
This may sound hard to believe today, but current events
have once again demonstrated that Mr. Buffett is pretty
much always right about the big things. He is calm and
optimistic when others are afraid and desperate. Berkshire
Hathaway stock has gone up 11.48% since our turmoil began,
and Mr. Buffett has another $30 or so billion to invest.
I believe his purchases will generate large returns for
us, and continue to be the safest stock investment in
the country - along with a number of our other stock-based
mutual funds.
Richard Morey
Secure Retirement
18 Crow Canyon Court
Suite 300
San Ramon, CA 94583
925-855-4300
|