|
Dear Investors,
We are simultaneously posting a report entitled Why the Worst May Soon Be Over from Bedlam Asset Management
in Britain. I apologize in advance for even bringing this article to your attention, as I do not believe it will
be possible for anyone to understand it if you don't have a pretty good understanding of European (and Asian
and U.S.) banking systems. In addition, the article is filled with fairly arcane references to financial
products and systems that few outside of the largest financial institutions had ever heard of before
September 15, 2008.
You might then ask why I would put this on our web site - surely not to torment my clients! But I have always
believed I should share all the knowledge I have for those few clients who want to know everything, and the
people at Bedlam Asset Management have presented the most comprehensive explanation of our situation from a
global perspective. While I do not agree with every idea they present, I would say a person cannot understand
much of what has been going on from a macroeconomic perspective unless you understand what they are talking
about in this article.
At the very least, you can learn more about this crisis by studying the European banking system's
near-collapse than you can by studying what has gone on in the U.S. This is because the Europeans bought more
of our terrible mortgage-related securities than we did. Plus, their largest banks bought into the insane
derivatives that nearly brought down the entire system, and they bought in very, very big. These are the
financial bond "insurance" policies, or "credit default swaps," the banks sold, to the tune of $40-$70 trillion
(depending on which economist is speaking) - guaranteeing that our mortgage market would never have a problem.
As I have shared before, Mr. Buffett called these (five years ago), "thermonuclear weapons" that, he implied,
would one day be unleashed on our financial systems.
Now Mr. Buffett knows a lot about thermonuclear weapons, as he owns one of the largest reinsurance
companies in the world, and one of those weapons going off in one of our cities is his single largest financial
risk. For example, he lost I believe (from memory) around $2 billion on 9/11 - I’m sure more than anyone else -
for his company was a major reinsurer of the Twin Towers. So when Mr. Buffett called the ballooning
derivatives market a thermonuclear weapon, I knew he meant exactly that. Of course, neither he, nor I, nor
anyone had any idea when this financial bomb might go off. It might never explode, as financial circumstances
change in unforeseen ways.
The answer to the question as to when it might explode would be September 15-26, in Europe. Fortunately for
everyone, it did not go off, but the countdown had begun. And that bomb, the destruction of a $40-$70 trillion
monster, was being accompanied by cataclysmic problems in every other area of our financial system. That
sounds like a pretty big bomb to me. In fact, you could look at any one of at least four distinct problems we
had that alone could nearly freeze up our credit markets.
But Europe was playing with the biggest bomb, the derivatives market/credit default swap/other insane
financial engineering products market. This is, you might recall, what brought down Bear Stearns, Lehman
Brothers, AIG and nearly Merrill Lynch. The people at Lehman and AIG guaranteed Chairman Bernanke that
everything would fall down if they fell, due to the trillions of dollars worth of interlocked, and now
nearly worthless, smorgasbord of complex financial products they all shared together. They had created
a monster, and they claimed it would bite the world economy’s head off if they were allowed to go bankrupt.
They gave the Fed a final warning that this would happen on the weekend of September 13-14.
But the Fed allowed Lehman Brothers to fall on September 15, which is the day the world markets went into
crisis and panic. Then, in the middle of the night on Sunday, September 28, I heard that Fortis, a huge
European bank, was collapsing. And then within a few days, seven of the largest banks in Europe were insolvent,
including the Royal Bank of Scotland and numerous other major British banks, nearly Ireland’s entire banking
system, perhaps Italy if truth were known, the entire nation of Iceland, etc. I suppose this could be a
coincidence, but it sounds to me as if the people at Lehman knew they had created a weapon that would wreak
financial havoc.
I was, I must admit, on "pins and needles" last Friday when Lehman Brothers' credit default swaps were
"valued." This was the first one of the $40-70 trillion worth of these things to be valued to see how much
money banks had lost. That was also, as I'm sure most of us will not soon forget, the day we were all wondering
whether or not we would end up in a depression. The Lehman credit default swaps were initially valued at 8.625%
of their original value, a loss of, it is estimated, at least $365 billion. And those are the losses from
exactly one out of the large number of our largest financial institutions that were on the other end of
Lehman's trades, and the trades they made with each other, etc. And the total liability when you combine all
the companies is somewhere between $40-70 trillion.
But the bomb did not go off. The last ingredient had been added, which is fear and a complete lack of
confidence in the financial system. And that last ingredient is the fuse. Once it is lit, things start to
move fast in the banking world. Without confidence, banks basically can't exist, as in order to function they
must be primarily involved in credit, which can't exist without confidence. And then when their stock prices
and assets start to fall quickly, as investors no longer have any confidence in them, certain regulatory
requirements/safeguards force them under in a few short days.
So the fuse was lit by last Friday. Fortunately, Britain responded like the responsible adults we always
hope they will be in a crisis. They moved very quickly to take the fuse out, i.e. to restore confidence in all
their major financial institutions. There is exactly one sure way to make sure the bomb wouldn't go off, and
that is for the government to back the banks. In a panic, only a government has enough credibility and staying
power to calm people's fears. Was there any financial company in the world you trusted implicitly last Friday?
No, whereas most expect Great Britain to weather the storm.
This has been an unusual time in many, many ways. One is that, since I saw this monster rearing its head on
September 8, I have felt that people would have panicked much sooner and much more if they saw everything I was
seeing! While I am one who always cautions calm when people start to panic, in this case the risk was so great
that a panic had to come if our entire financial system was about to collapse. Forget calm - I want that bomb
defused right now.
Had Britain not removed the fuse, Europe would have taken the direct hit of this "thermonuclear weapon." Its
entire financial system would have been wiped out - this week. We would have been decimated here in the U.S.,
but Europe was going to be annihilated.
So I have been studying Europe to get a clearer picture of how the many financial dangers we have been
facing look, and how/what/who they destroy. Europe went closer to the brink than we did, and anyone who needs
to protect against investment risk needs to know everything possible about the dangers they saw up close, in
order to make sure we control and avoid risk should we approach that brink again.
This in no way means that you need to understand everything that has gone on from a macroeconomic
perspective! That's my job, another part of which is to educate and share ideas so you get the amount of
information you want and need, and we all become better investors.
Finally, please know that I do not think my analysis presented in this short report more than begins to
explain the entirety of what has gone on in recent weeks. In fact, the article by Bedlam Asset Management
gives a much more comprehensive analysis. I am, however, fairly confident I am following a deadly thread
running through this crisis. Looked at from every angle, this has been one of the most dangerous times in
economic history. I recommend we remain vigilant until we are certain it has passed.
Next week, after taking a few days off after a very long six weeks, we will be posting the results from
a mathematical analysis of the risk we have been experiencing in recent weeks and months. I promise no math
knowledge or ability will be required to understand it. But if you are interested in risk control, it might
not put you to sleep.
Richard Morey
Secure Retirement
18 Crow Canyon Court
Suite 300
San Ramon, CA 94583
925-855-4300
|